Court Orders Final Forfeiture Of 48 Malami’s Properties

0

The Federal High Court in Abuja ,on Wednesday, ordered the final forfeiture of 48 properties linked to former Attorney General of the Federation and minister of Justice, Abubakar Malami.

 

 

Judge Joyce Abdulmalik granted the forfeiture application by the Economic and Financial Crimes Commission (EFCC), holding that, Mr Malami and others laying claim to the assets failed to prove they lawfully acquired them.

 

 

The properties include hotels, a university, malls, corporate entities, residential houses scattered in Abuja, Kaduna, Kano and Birnin-Kebbi, the capital of Kebbi State from where Mr Malami hails.

 

 

However, Judge Abdulmalik released only nine out of the 57 assets the EFCC presented for final forfeiture. The judge said, EFCC did not convincingly prove that the nine assets were illegitimately acquired.

 

 

EFCC instituted forfeiture proceedings in January against 57 assets worth more than N212 billion, alleging Mr Malami acquired them with proceeds of unlawful activities while serving as AGF between 2015 and 2023.

 

 

The court, presided over by another judge, issued an interim forfeiture order against all 57 properties in January.

 

 

Mr Malami and 14 others, including his family members, his university, hotels and corporate entities affected by the ruling, filed processes to challenge the interim order, maintaining that they had legitimately acquired the assets.

 

 

The former minister’s family members among the challengers are his sons, Abdulaziz and Abiru, and his wife, Ms Bashir.

 

 

The challengers also include Rayhaan Bustan and Agro Allied Ltd, Moutain View Gold and Jewellery Ltd, Amasdul Oil and Gas Limited, Azbir Arena Nigeria Ltd, Meethaq Hotels Ltd, Rayhaan University Ltd/GTE, Rayhaan Hotels Ltd and Zeenoor Hotels Ltd.

 

 

The rest are Kwasar Ben of Brahim, Mutkataka Usman Junju and Real Edge Agro Services. Ms Abdulmalik ruled that the issue before the court was not “who owns the property, but how legitimate are the funds used to acquire the properties.”

 

 

According to the judge, the respondents had “not dislodged the reasonable suspicion that the property was acquired by unlawful activities.”

 

 

Relying principally on Section 17 of the Advance Fee Fraud and Other Fraud Related Offences Act to grant the final forfeiture order, the judge held that Mr Malami and his co-respondents failed to “rebut the reasonable suspicion” that the properties were acquired through unlawful activities.

 

 

The judge said, the evidence before the court showed that Mr Malami earned N89.7 million (N89,664,000) as salary while serving as minister between 2015 and 2023.

 

 

She added that, he received N12 million (N12,158,400) as severance allowance at the end of his tenure.

 

 

The judge also noted that, Mr Malami declared N253.6 million (N253,608,500) as official earnings in an addendum to his asset declaration submitted to the Code of Conduct Bureau in a letter dated 16 June 2023.

 

 

The judge said the evidence showed that Mr Malami, while acting as guarantor to Raywan Retails Ltd for a Zenith Bank facility, declared before a notary public on 10 September 2020 that his personal assets were N41 million and his monthly net income after expenses was N397,000.

 

 

She also considered evidence relating to companies under the Raywan Group of Companies, noting that several of the companies were incorporated during Mr Malami’s tenure as minister between 2015 and 2023.

 

The respondents had challenged the valuation reports relied upon by the EFCC, arguing that they were inaccurate.

 

But Judge Abdulmalik rejected the respondents’ argument, holding that valuation was “not based on any mathematical certainty” because different valuers could arrive at different figures.

 

 

She held that Section 17 of the Advance Fee Fraud and Other Fraud Related Offences Act does not make the production of valuation reports a requirement before a court can grant interim or final forfeiture orders.

 

 

“The relevant statutory threshold remains the existence of reasonable suspicion,” the judge held. The respondents had also argued that there was no concluded criminal charge against Mr Malami.

 

Judge Abdulmalik held that forfeiture proceedings under Section 17(6) of the Act do not depend on a criminal conviction or the filing of criminal charges.

 

She held that such proceedings are targeted at the property and not the owner. The judge also rejected the respondents’ explanation regarding the alleged loan used to acquire some of the properties.

 

 

She held that there was no evidence showing “a traceable repayment history” linked to lawful income, business records or legitimate financial transactions.

 

She said, “Although the properties stand and exist, the question remains: From what source were they acquired?”

 

 

“In view of the material placed before the court, I find that the applicant acted in accordance with the law in conducting its investigation of the first respondent,” she held.

 

 

She added that “in the absence of any evidence in answer to show lawful source of payments,” the EFCC had established a prima facie case that the 48 properties were proceeds of unlawful activities.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *