Petrol Subsidy Return May Cost Nigeria N20trn Annually — CPPE

0
CEO, CPPE, Dr. Muda Yusuf

BY CEES HARMON

The Chief Executive Officer of the Centre for the Promotion of Private Enterprise (CPPE), Dr Muda Yusuf, has warned that restoring the universal petrol subsidy could expose Nigeria to an annual fiscal burden of about N20 trillion, urging the Federal Government to focus instead on targeted relief measures to cushion the impact of rising fuel prices.
Yusuf said the recent surge in petrol prices has imposed severe pressures on households and businesses, driving up transportation, logistics and production costs, weakening purchasing power and further threatening the competitiveness of micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs).
However, he cautioned against a return to the old subsidy regime, which he described as fiscally unsustainable and responsible for significant distortions in Nigeria’s foreign exchange market, public finances and petroleum downstream sector.

According to him, the policy debate should move beyond whether petrol subsidy should be restored to how government can preserve the gains of the reform while reducing its social costs.

Yusuf said that before subsidy removal, Nigeria spent an estimated $10 billion to $15 billion annually on petroleum-product imports, while subsidy and under-recovery obligations consumed substantial public resources and constrained revenues available for the three tiers of government.
He noted that artificially low domestic petrol prices also encouraged arbitrage and cross-border diversion, effectively resulting in Nigerian resources being used to subsidise fuel consumption outside the country.
“The old regime was therefore not merely a subsidy problem; it was a major fiscal, foreign-exchange and resource-allocation problem,” he said.

*N20TRN SUBSIDY BILL*
Yusuf warned that reinstating a universal subsidy at current market conditions could create an enormous fiscal exposure for the Federal Government.
Using an estimated petrol consumption benchmark of 50 million litres per day and an indicative subsidy requirement of N1,050 per litre, he estimated the potential cost at approximately N52.5 billion daily, N1.575 trillion monthly and N19.16 trillion annually.

He stressed that the actual cost would depend on crude-oil prices, exchange rates, refining or landing costs, consumption levels and the regulated pump price, adding that consumption could rise under a subsidy regime as price differentials recreate incentives for smuggling and cross-border diversion.
Yusuf warned that an annual subsidy bill approaching N20trillion would impose a huge opportunity cost on the economy, competing with expenditure on infrastructure, healthcare, education, security, agriculture and social protection.

He added that increased government borrowing to finance such a subsidy could worsen fiscal deficits, raise debt-service pressures and crowd out private-sector credit, thereby sustaining high interest rates and weakening investment, productivity and job creation.

“Nigeria would risk replacing an energy-price problem with a much larger fiscal, debt, foreign-exchange and investment problem,” he warned.

*DON’T BLAME ALL PRICE HIKES ON SUBSIDY REMOVAL*
The CPPE boss also urged policymakers and the public to distinguish between the structural price adjustment caused by subsidy removal and the latest increase driven by global energy-market shocks.
He noted that petrol sold at about N774–N800 per litre before the latest escalation in international energy prices, but subsequently rose above N1,300 per litre amid the sharp increase in global crude-oil and refined-product prices linked to the Middle East crisis.

According to him, attributing the entire increase in petrol prices to subsidy removal would therefore be misleading.
He described the two developments as separate issues requiring different policy responses: subsidy removal represents a domestic structural reform, while the latest price surge is largely an external commodity-price shock..
.
*REFINING GAINS MUST BE PROTECTED*
Yusuf further argued that market-based petrol pricing has improved the commercial viability of domestic refining after decades of administratively suppressed prices and uncertainty.

He said the expansion of domestic refining could generate benefits beyond petrol production, creating opportunities in diesel, aviation fuel, petrochemicals, fertiliser, plastics, chemicals, logistics, storage and maritime services.

He urged the government to maintain a predictable, market-oriented framework capable of attracting further investment and positioning Nigeria as a competitive regional refining and petrochemical hub.
“Domestic refining also conserves foreign exchange through import substitution, creates export opportunities and retains refining, engineering, logistics and technical jobs within the Nigerian economy,” he said.

*TARGETED RELIEF, NOT UNIVERSAL SUBSIDY*
While acknowledging the severe cost-of-living pressures confronting Nigerians, Yusuf said government intervention should target the sources of household vulnerability and high business costs rather than subsidise petrol consumption indiscriminately.

He called for massive investment in affordable mass transit, rail freight and logistics infrastructure, alongside improvements in electricity supply and accelerated deployment of CNG, solar and distributed-energy solutions.

He also advocated stronger support for food production through agricultural security, irrigation, rural infrastructure and improved productivity, as well as targeted social protection for vulnerable households.
According to him, government must equally improve affordable public healthcare and education while reducing energy, logistics and financing costs for productive enterprises, particularly MSMEs.

Yusuf said, the fiscal gains from subsidy removal must become more visible in the lives of Nigerians through improved infrastructure, public services and productive investment.

He also demanded greater transparency and accountability from the Federal, State and Local Governments on how additional resources accruing from the reform are being deployed.

“The appropriate policy direction is to preserve the downstream petroleum reforms while aggressively mitigating their social and economic costs,” Yusuf said.

He maintained that the ultimate test of the reform would not simply be the amount of revenue saved by government, but whether Nigeria could translate those gains into lower structural costs, stronger domestic production, greater energy security, improved competitiveness and measurable improvements in citizens’ welfare.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *